For 40 years (1980-2019), bond investors in the US earned a rate of return that outpaced inflation, and often by a wide margin:
- In the 1980s, 10-year yields moved from 10.4% down to 7.8%, and bond investors earned an annualized real return of 6.6%.
- In the 1990s, 10-year yields moved from 7.8% down to 6.3%, and bond investors earned an annualized real return of 4.4%.
- From 2000 to 2019, 10-year yields moved from 6.3% down to 1.9%, and bond investors earned an annualized real return of 3.5%
But that was the past. It’s hard to fathom such lofty returns as we find ourselves in a very different environment today.
With a 10-year Treasury yield of 1.6% and inflation at 4.1%, the current real yield of -2.5% is the lowest since 1980 (real yield = nominal yield minus inflation).
Is this good or bad value for Treasury bond investors? And what does it suggest, if anything, for real returns going forward? Let’s take a look at the historical evidence…
We have monthly inflation data (CPI) in the US going back to 1948. Since then, the average real yield on 10-year Treasury bonds has been 2.1%.
Does that mean we always see real yields around 2.1%? No, far from it.
There have been many periods in which real yields have been significantly higher or lower than the historical median. This includes times during which real yields have been negative (16% of the time) and other times when real yield have been above 4% (17% of the time).
Following the peak in yields/inflation in the early 1980s, bond yields remained stubbornly high even as inflation cooled. This resulted in a bonanza for bond investors as they earned yields substantially above the inflation rate (5.7% median real yield from 1981-1989) and benefited from a decline in interest rates (15% in 1981 to 7% in 1989). In the 1990s, the good times continued. As inflation cooled even further, bond yields were again slow to react, leading to a 3.6% median real yield from 1991-1999.
Over the past 5 years, we’ve seen much more challenging times for bond investors, with real yields falling to a median level of 0.2%. This is lowest for any 5-year period since the late 1940s/early 1950s.
Do low real yields imply low real returns?
Not necessarily. There’s a difference between a current real yield (= yield minus inflation rate) and a future real return (function of yield, future inflation, and changes in yield).
Real yields were negative in October 1980 and over the next decade bonds would produce their best real returns in history. This was a function of the high starting yield (12.5%), a persistent decline in interest rates (7.5% by October 1990), and a sharp decline in inflation (12.6% in October 1980 to 6.4% in October 1990).
Unfortunately for bond investors, the low real yields of today are not in any way comparable to October 1980. 10-Year yields hit all-time lows last year and since then both yields and inflation have been rising, not falling.
The 1950s may prove to be a more instructive comparison. Inflation averaged only 2.2% from 1950-1959 but bonds would produce a negative real return of 1.5% per year as yields rose from 2.3% to 4.7%. As you can see in the table below, a decade or more of negative real returns is not unprecedented; we just haven’t seen it in some time.
Which means that at the end of 2029, we could very well be looking back at a negative real return for bonds over the prior 10 years.
That’s not to suggest bonds have no place in a portfolio today (see here for their role), but that bond investors need to keep their expectations in check. The 40-year bull market in long-term bonds (1981-2019) generated abnormal real returns, particularly during the 1980s (6.6%) and 1990s (4.4%). But the factors that led to those strong returns (high starting yields, potential for falling yields/inflation) are no longer in place today. In fact, the complete opposite is true (low starting yields, potential for rising yields/inflation).
Given this backdrop, what real returns should bond investors expect?
Below the historical average (2% since 1948) would seem to be reasonable starting point. The Golden Age for bonds is over.
Stocks, Bonds and Higher Inflation
The Most Important Rule in Investing
The Price of Admission in Bonds
To sign up for our free newsletter, click here.
Disclaimer: All information provided is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, legal or tax advice, or an offer to buy or sell any security. For our full disclosures, click here.