Is This 1929 or 1998?

By Charlie Bilello

10 Feb 2021

The CAPE Ratio just crossed above 39.1

In layman’s terms, what exactly does that mean?

Equity valuations in the US are quite high.

How high?

Going back to 1871, the only periods in history with a CAPE above 39 are as follows…

  • September 1929
  • March 1998 to January 2001
  • Today

In September 1929, the CAPE ratio moved above 39 for the first time in history. That same month, the S&P 500 would hit a generational high. From there, it would fall over 86% before bottoming in June 1932.

In March 1998, the CAPE ratio moved above 39 for the second time in history. From there, the S&P 500 would gain another 44% before peaking in March 2000. From the peak in March 2000 to the low in October 2002, the S&P 500 would give back all of those gains and more, declining over 50%.

So is this 1929 or 1998?

Neither. This is 2021.

No one knows what will happen from here because every time is different (see rule #4). Valuations may be the same as these years, but the path ahead most certainly won’t be.

Stocks could fall starting tomorrow (1929 example) or they could run for a few more years (1998 example), going from overvalued to more overvalued.

Or they could trade in a sideways range for years to come, frustrating bulls and bears alike.

Literally anything can happen in the short-run that is determined by sentiment (fear and greed) more than anything else. We shouldn’t be surprised by any of it.

That said, with the CAPE ratio above 39 (98th percentile), what should investors be prepared for in the longer-run?

1) Below average forward returns…

2) Above average forward volatility…

3) Above average forward maximum loss…2

These are just averages and probabilities based on what has happened in the past at similar valuation junctures. There are always exceptions to the rule, and as we saw from 1998 trying to time the market based on valuation is a fools game. There is nothing stopping investors today from bidding up stocks to even higher multiples.

But an objective observer will note that the risk/reward in US equities is less favorable today than it has been in quite some time. That says nothing about what will happen tomorrow, but if the price one pays for something still matters, it will be a factor weighing on returns for years to come.

After the CAPE ratio hit 39 in 1929, the S&P 500 would trade at the same level 25 years later – in 1954.

After the CAPE ratio hit 39 in 1998, the S&P 500 would trade at the same level 12 years later – in 2010.

This is not 1929 or 1998, but investors are faced with a similar question: with the CAPE ratio above 39 once more, how many years into the future will the S&P 500’s current level of 3900 be revisited?

1. In this post, the CAPE Ratio is the Cyclically Adjusted Total Return Price to Earnings Ratio (TR P/E10 or TR CAPE). It is also known as the “Shiller P/E” as it was developed by economist Robert Shiller. Data source: Robert Shiller.

2. Maximum loss is calculated by taking the lowest monthly future closing value over x number years (1-10) and comparing that to the starting value.

To sign up for our free newsletter, click here.

Disclaimer: All information provided is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, legal or tax advice, or an offer to buy or sell any security. For our full disclosures, click here.

About the author

Share this post

Recent posts
The Epic Small Cap Surge – Chart of the Day (7/16/24)
The Week in Charts (7/15/24)